CatVerdict is a small, independent site run by one person — there’s no in-house testing lab, no staff veterinarian, and no sponsored “review team.” Being upfront about that is part of being honest with you, and it’s exactly why we’re careful about how we put each guide together.
Our Research Process
Every pick on CatVerdict goes through the same research steps before it’s included in a guide:
- Specs & ingredients: We compare the manufacturer’s published specs, ingredient lists, and (for food) AAFCO nutritional statements against what’s actually needed for the use case in question.
- Real owner reviews: We read through verified-purchase reviews on retailers like Amazon and Chewy, looking specifically for recurring patterns — the same complaint or the same praise showing up across many independent buyers.
- Vet-reviewed & authoritative sources: Where health, safety, or nutrition claims are involved, we cross-check against established veterinary and welfare organizations (AAFCO, AVMA, ASPCA, Cornell Feline Health Center, TICA/CFA for breed facts) rather than marketing copy.
- Price & value: We weigh price against what a product actually delivers, and flag when a cheaper or pricier option isn’t worth the difference.
- Safety & recall checks: We check for open recalls or documented safety issues before recommending anything.
What We Don’t Do
We don’t claim hands-on product testing, and we don’t put a vet’s name on anything a vet didn’t actually write or review. If a guide ever says “vet-reviewed sources,” that means the research draws on material published by veterinary and welfare organizations — not that a veterinarian reviewed the page itself. We’d rather be clear about that than borrow authority we don’t have.
How We Rank Our Top Picks
Rankings and “best for” labels reflect an editorial judgment call based on the research above — how well a product’s specs and ingredients match the use case, how consistent real owner feedback is, and how it stacks up on price versus value. They’re our best read of the available evidence, not a guaranteed outcome for every cat, which is one more reason individual pros/cons and “who it’s best for” notes matter more than the star rating alone.
Questions about how a specific recommendation was made? Get in touch — see also our affiliate disclosure.
